Palace Under Fire for Failed McNeil Move
Dwight McNeil’s transfer from Everton to Crystal Palace collapsed late on deadline day, leaving the winger and his partner frustrated. McNeil’s partner, Megan Sharpley, criticized Palace for “messing” with the player’s mental health after the deal fell through.
The Premier League club had agreed on a loan-to-buy deal for McNeil, which included a £20 million permanent transfer. McNeil had completed a medical, and Palace submitted a deal sheet before the 19:00 GMT deadline.
However, while Everton completed their paperwork, Palace failed to finalize their documents in time. Sharpley said the couple experienced “radio silence” from the club during the crucial hours.
Emotional Toll on McNeil
Sharpley shared on social media that a four-and-a-half-year contract had been offered, and the couple had prepared to relocate hundreds of miles. The sudden cancellation left them heartbroken.
“We all deserve to be treated with respect, kindness, and fairness. The last 48 hours have shown how cruel the football world can be,” she wrote.
McNeil also expressed disappointment at the lack of communication but confirmed his commitment to Everton. “I am an Everton player. I will use this as motivation,” he said. Everton publicly supported their player, posting: “Still one of us and a big few months ahead. Everyone at Everton is behind you Dwight.”
What Went Wrong
The deal initially agreed between the clubs included a guaranteed £12 million with £8 million in performance bonuses. Palace argued that while an agreement in principle existed, the structure and add-ons were still under discussion.
The Eagles believed McNeil would be available for £10 million, but formal negotiations revealed the full cost would reach £20 million. Palace submitted a deal sheet to the Premier League, allowing final negotiations to continue beyond the deadline, but the deal ultimately fell through.
Palace sources expressed sympathy and apologized for the distress McNeil experienced.
Wider Issue in Football Transfers
This incident highlights a broader problem in football. Players often face mental stress and uncertainty during transfers. BBC Sport sources said some players are notified of moves via text or last-minute instructions, adding to the emotional toll.
One parent said, “It’s simplified from the outside. Club A moves a player to Club B, but in reality, it’s a lot more complex. Players are treated like assets and often without a human touch.”
The Professional Footballers’ Association advises players and monitors their welfare, but experts say clubs need to handle transfers more thoughtfully.
